My Photo

Filmi Geek's blogs

Become a Fan

Filmi Geek on Twitter

    follow me on Twitter

    « Pyar to hona hi tha (1998) | Main | Chhupa Rustam (1973) »

    August 03, 2008

    Comments

    Jabberwock

    "Javed Akhtar once said that Hollywood films are short stories while Hindi films are novels. But the characterizations and scope of Main Azaad hoon are, in some ways, more like the former."

    Interesting observation, given that the basic plot structure of Main Azaad Hoon is borrowed from Frank Capra's 1941 film Meet John Doe. Thankfully they haven't simply lifted the original script but have tried to work in an Indian context.

    Incidentally, this film made a lot of news back when it was going to be released, because it was the first time that Amitabh was appearing in a "non-mainstream" role (at a time when the lines were very clearly drawn in Hindi cinema and he had been doing only commercial roles for years). I remember how curious we all were at the prospect of seeing Amitabh doing a (relatively) "realistic" film without the obligatory six song sequences.

    memsaab

    I'll have to add this to my list of must-see...

    carla

    Jabberwock, thanks very much for the comments. It's interesting to know that this film was Amitabh's first relatively non-mainstream effort. There were five or six song sequences as it happened but they were all repetitions of the same song - a solidarity anthem that he sang to stir the spirit of social change among his followers. It didn't make the final cut in my review (I like to try to keep them brief) but I had wanted to lodge that small complaint about the film - by the end I really didn't want to hear that song again.

    Memsaab: You know I will always be happy to watch it with you. Two hours with you and Shabana Azmi would be about as fine a two hours as I could hope for.

    Ramesh

    (like I said in an email to you)

    Sorry to bust your opinionated bubble somewhat, but your javed sahib only reworked(stole) the screenpaly of a rajinikanth film (Naan mahaan alla) which the producers had bought rights to remake into hindi.

    ajnabi

    I've only heard good things about this film, but for some reason it hasn't been in my (ever lengthening) queue over at Netflix. I'll have to go see if I can remedy that.

    the ppcc

    Looks incredibly interesting! Like Remington Steele meets Frank Capra meets... Amitabh Bachchan?! Fab!

    shweta

    While I havent seen the Frank Capra original, I truly did enjoy this film. It was definitely a different movie for Amitabh to try, and a throwback to the slightly non mainstream ones he began with- Rema aur Shera, and Saat Hindustani. It makes me wonder if his talent was never truly explored properly- with all the showmanship, perhaps the actor never got much of a chance :)

    carla

    ajnabi: Does Netflix have this one? Netflix's collection of Hindi films has grown like crazy over the past couple of years. I remember looking for Shabana Azmi movies three years ago, and they had about 6 titles, three of which were Hollywood films she had been in like *Madame Souzatska* and *Son of the Pink Panther*.

    PPCC: I think you might like this one, though you'll probably find it a little slow and talky.

    Shweta: I wonder about that too. I am a huge fan of Amitabh's films pre-stardom; I especially love films like *Saudagar* where he plays a really morally bad character so compellingly. It's quite different from the Angry Young Man who may have been lawless, but always had a good solid heart. I am going to have to check out *Reshma aur Shera* and *Saat Hindustani*, neither of which I have seen.

    shweta

    And I must see "Saudagar," which I didnt know about at all! While SRK made a habit of -ve roles, I find pre-90s heros playing -ve parts v interesting. Thanks for the recommendation :)

    ajnabi

    Carla, it does have it--on DVD and available for Instant Viewing as well.

    quarkLore

    I remember watching it after a long time and I liked the movie copied or not.

    The ending matching with ending of "V for Vendetta" seemed uncanny, even if superficial.

    A friend of mine, not a great critic, said that the garb that Amitabh wore was like a Russian labour. I don't know how true or false it is but it was surely a lot different from what you see in real or reel life. The discourses that all the characters have between them where indeed very good.

    I particularly liked the sequence when Shabana's boss unravels her plans. The face contortions in that guy's acting is awesome. ( I do not remember his name but he was laudable in Mahesh Bhatt's Daddy too)

    "Parallel" or perpendicular I like movies which can bind me, are coherent (vis-a-vis real, what I mean is they are not flimsy yet create a non-conflicting world of their own).

    I shall see the Frank Capra original too.

    maajhi

    क्या बात है फ़िल्मीगीकजी, आजकल आप न रीव्यूज़ लिखती हैं न हिन्दी सीखने की बातें करती हैं? कुछ नए इण्ट्रेस्ट्स् आगे आए हैं क्या? ज़रा हमें भी तो बताएँ …

    carla

    Maajhi thanks for thinking of me. There is no new interest taking up my time. In fact I am simply very tired and a little depressed, working on staying focused on my job and having trouble finding the energy for the things I ordinarily love to do. I am not doing much of anything.

    I have a review half-written and a few more in the wings, and I am still watching movies and will try to get caught up soon.

    The Comic Project

    A copy of Meet John Doe, I liked this film. "Azaad, itne unche mat udo" - Manohar Singh acting was great.

    Please blog more often :-)

    www.thecomicproject.blogspot.com

    Jugnu

    I loved the background music in this movie. The same background music is also used in JP Dutta's Hathyaar. Does anyone know if the background music is inspired/copied from somewhere?

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Working...
    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    Working...

    Post a comment

    Blog powered by TypePad

    Blogosphere