My Photo

Become a Fan

Filmi Geek on Twitter

    follow me on Twitter

    « Antareen (1994) | Main | Hum tum (2004) »

    June 19, 2007

    Comments

    Meera

    Hi Carla

    Good review as usual. Sharmila Tagore won the Best Actor National Award for this movie.

    She is one of the talented actresses of the 60s and 70s. I would recommend you see her blockbluster hit with Rajesh Khanna "Aradhna" - this movie was very famous for its songs too.

    Another good movie of hers with Dharmendra is Mere Hum Dum Mere Dost - an entertaining bollywood film.

    Her truly good serious movies are Anupama and Satyakam - both Hrisikesh Mukherjee movies.

    I was lucky to see these old movies on Indian Television when i was in Uni!

    cheers

    Meera

    Carla

    Some of the best movies of Sanjeev Kumar are - Anamika, Khilona, Koshish (he and Jaya Bahaduri are deaf and dumb in the movie), Anhonee, Pati, Patni aur Woh (comedy).

    Happy viewing

    Daddy's Girl

    Interesting review - 'Mausam' sounds like something I'd definitely want to see. I agree with your asessment of Sharmila's acting - I usually find her very convincing.

    yves

    Hi Carla,

    Thanks for this nice review. What's the connection between the story and its title?
    Yves

    carla

    Meera: thanks for the recommendations for both Sharmila and Sanjeev. I have thought about watching *Arudhana* because of the famous "Roop tera mastana" song, but I have not really warmed to Rajesh Khanna and that fact keeps stopping me.

    Daddy's Girl: I'm definitely a Sharmila believer.

    Yves: Your guess is as good as mine. It may play on some usage or connotation of the word "mausam" that I am not familiar with.

    Beth

    What were the implications and undertones of Gil's attraction to Kajli? It sounds kinda creepy, but I'm assuming you would have mentioned that if you found it so. Ditto the idea of his "project" - does it seem at all that he's trying to turn her into something that she fundamentally isn't? Or is his goal more a better version of her true self? Does she welcome molding? I'm really wary of stories that involve men saving women (and being a little turned on by their savior role), so I'm really curious how this one plays out; I know you are very likely to be bothered by some of these kinds of issues too and probably wouldn't give such an encouraging review to a movie that had some of that slant of skeeze in it.

    Meera

    Beth - there is nothing sleazy in the movie. Watch it for yourself.

    Yves and Carla - Mausam in hindi means "season". I guess the title is referring to the changing facets of life like the changing seasons (weather). Mausam is also used in the context of weather especially in hindi news bulletins.

    In fact the song that you liked so much Carla has a reference to the changing seasons, ie, dhil doontha hai phir wahi phursat ke raat din".

    carla

    Thanks Meera. I had given the meaning "season" in the review; I suppose you are right that it refers to the changeable nature of life like the seasons (or, more unpredictably, like weather). I still find that rather oblique and metaphoric, but it wouldn't be the only Hindi film titled in an oblique and metaphoric way.

    Beth, Meera is right that it is not sleazy, and you are right that it is hard to explain why it is not. I think it works because of Gil's sadness and desperation; he's not superior to her, he just wants her mother back. And while he must be attracted to her he never touches her, which also preserves the purity and internality (internal to Gil) of his feelings, if that makes any sense.

    Darshana of Bollywhat

    I'll make a pass at the topic of the title, Mausam, meaning "season." To me the essence of the movie and its greatness have to do with its evocation of the experience of: long-ago days, how they felt, and poignant regret about them.

    The song at the very beginning reached me there - Dil Doondtha Hai. As the movie starts you hear this, and follow a car driving up through the forests of a hill station. The words are transtlated as something like - "the heart lies in search/ of those lost days and nights of leisure. . . " Therein to me is "season."

    Then - the story is about Dr Gil/Sanjeev K's return to that place from his own life, and his aching regret about what is gone forever.

    Anonymous

    I just saw this film based on your review and enjoyed it. Thanks for the helpful posts -- keep the reivews coming! And I am a Sharmila fan from the good work she did with Satyajit Ray. If you haven't seen it, put "Aranyer Din Ratri" on your list. It's a great film and a great performance by Sharmila.

    Sally

    carla

    Sally, thanks so much. I was amazed by Sharmila's performance in *Apur Sansar* when she was all of 14 years old and that definitely made me want to check out the other work she did with Satyajit Ray.

    Nautilus

    If you want to see the variety Sanjeev Kumar could offer would recommend that you see Angoor, it is based on Shakespeare's play 'The Comedy of Errors' and has Sanjeev Kumar in double role; movie has been written and directed by Gulzar

    carla

    Thanks Nautilus. I have wanted to see this movie for some time and have not been able to track down a copy for myself. I am sure I will see it some day.

    Aham

    yes, this one for sure is a masterpiece. A throbbing tale told very beautifully.

    dimps

    Mausam an excellent movie by the grat gulzar & sanjeev!

    Awsome sharmila

    I was not close ro sharmila till now but after seing this movie...
    have no words to describe
    simply superb movie

    Subba Raman

    Most fans assume (as does Carla in this review) that the elder Dr. Gil went to Darjeeling with the "mission" of tracking down Chanda. Based on the flow of the conversation he has at the roadside tea shop the first morning after his return visit, I believe the story teller is conveying that this mission is not something Dr. Gil had planned on before his visit but is gradually drawn into after. As he discovers in increments the life Chanda was condemned to, he starts to take increasing responsibility to do something about it. Further proof of this is that at the time he arrives at the guest house in Darjeeling, he jokes lightheartedly with some professional colleagues about his involvement with a girl during his earlier visit. Given the portrayal of his character in the rest of the movie, it is hard to imagine him joking that way about Chanda unless he was under the impression she would have moved on and settled in her life.

    Nadja

    Good review. I saw this film for the first time recently and was very impressed with the acting, particularly Kumar. I admit that up till now I only knew him in Sholay - I was impressed with his performance there too.
    There is a lot of sadness in this film which the fairly upbeat ending (both characters with the promise of a new start) does little to dispel. I found myself crying fairly heartily at the end.
    I did feel that having Chanda lose her marbles after her diasastrous marriage was one melodramatic touch too far, that's the only real criticism I can think of. The brothel was depicted in a very matter-of-fact way, still very unusual for maintream Hindi film.
    Overall, one of the better Hindi films I've seen.

    Nitin

    I think Sanjeev Kumar's Work in Koshish should go down as Hindi Film Industry's One of the Best Performances. He is so natural in almost any role he portrays. Just the kind of Enigma he held his entire life was unfailingly part of his performances.

    I am big big fan of him. Sometimes feel sad when only the Larger Than Life Heroes are celebrated in Hindi Film Industry and names like Sanjeev Kumar are somehow suppressed in the background.

    Nitin

    And by the way good review, Carla

    carla

    Thanks Nitin, I really appreciate your comments. Hope to see you here again!

    I can't wait to see *Koshish*. Every time I mention to someone my admiration for Sanjeev Kumar, *Koshish* is the next word out of their mouth.

    Bosco

    R.D.s hauntingly beautiful numbers, especially the starting music of 'Dil dhoondta hain (slow)' simply transports you to a different world. Also, the song picturization by Gulzar only adds to the magic.

    carla

    Thanks for the comment, Bosco. Can't agree more about "Dil dhoondta hai".

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Working...
    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    Working...

    Post a comment