My Photo

Filmi Geek's blogs

Become a Fan

Filmi Geek on Twitter

    follow me on Twitter

    « Eklavya (2007) | Main | The Guru (2002) »

    February 26, 2007

    Comments

    Daddy's Girl

    I was going to give this one a miss, as it seemed like the sort of contrived comedy I usually hate. But your review makes it sound worth watching and I have grown to trust your judgment - I think I just might be headed to the cinema when it comes out here next week.

    Congrats on your 20th Shabana film!

    Sanni

    >>Honeymoon Travels was my 20th Shabana film!
    Congrats! I've *technically* also seen 20 of my favourite's films (one is technically unfinished thanks to crappy DVD). Of course, you have many, many, MANY more films to go whereas I, uhh, don't. :D But eh, soon.

    As for this film, hmmm, will have to see about seeing it when the DVD is out. I'll gladly watch Boman in anything but Amisha Patel? Er, not so much. Good to know you think positively of it, though.

    carla

    Daddy's Girl: I think if one's expectations are in line with what the film is offering, the movie will be rewarding. There are parts that are side-splittingly funny, anyhow.

    Sanni: I have no strong feelings about Amisha Patel, one way or the other. I can say that though her character had a brief song she wasn't really a focus of the film. So I don't think there's enough of her to get in the way.

    Daddy's Girl

    Hi, I just saw this and liked it - so thanks! I wouldn't have seen it if not for your review. It was an enjoyable two hours. Having seen the movie, I agree with just about everything you've said. Oh, and your favourite did a great job. As you noted, her closing speech was a bit preachy, but it summed everything up pretty well. Shame about Vikram Chatwal, though. One gets the feeling he tried his best, but it wasn't nearly good enough - especially opposite Sandhya Mridul, who I thought did very well with her role.

    carla

    I am so glad you liked it, Daddy's Girl - I feel like stumping for this film, as I really loved it and I want it to be noticed. I can't wait until the DVD comes out - I want to see it again and see if it stands up to my tasty memories of it.

    maxqnz

    I'd give this film 8.5 for intention and 6.75 for execution. Less would have been more, specifically one fewer couple. For example if Madhu's husband had found his love interest outside of the Vicky-Pinky pairing, that pair could have been removed, and more time would have been available for looking at the couples that were left. Also, I found the "resolution" of the madhu/bunty joDi unsatisfying. Such marriages have worked, and many probably still are, but as surprises go, that's a doozy, and I doubt the trust issues raised by having that one thrown at you AFTER the shaadi would be smoothed over quite that quickly.

    I liked Kay Kay's character, and found his stiff insecurity very believable. But it was unquestionably Mr and Mrs 55 who carried and redeemed the movie. Except for "hit them over the head with the message" sermon at the end, every scene of theirs was a standout. I especially liked their conversation with Ditta, where Boman's character gently mocked her Orientalism, and Shabana's gently chiding foot tap seemed exactly right for a couple who were friends long before they were a couple.

    I'm going to have to try to watch the last 10 minutes again, as the DVD kept skipping, and I want to make sute I haven't missed anything that might improve the film for me. Thanks for the review, Carla, and for pointing me to yet another film that challenges my ageist bias against modern Hindi cinema.

    carla

    With this movie, perhaps more than any other, I feel a little surge of almost maternal pride every time someone discovers it and falls in love with it. I am so glad you liked it, maxqnz, as it is and remains a favorite of mine. In fact, last weekend I watched it for perhaps the fourth time and loved it just as much as the first.

    My feeling about Bunty and Madhu - Pinky and Vicky, too, actually - is that their stories have not resolved, even though they seem content at the film's close. The film is merciful enough, to them and to us, to leave them at a moment of temporary peace. But we know that they have a lot of work ahead of them, and they (with the exception of Pinky) probably know it too.

    Oh - and the scene you mentioned, where Oscar and Naheed spin for Ditta that beautiful metaphorical tall tale of how they met - is my ABSOLUTE favorite scene in the film, bar none. As Naheed says, muqarrar!

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Working...
    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    Working...

    Post a comment

    Blog powered by TypePad

    Blogosphere