My Photo

Become a Fan

Filmi Geek on Twitter

    follow me on Twitter

    « Silsila (1981) | Main | Filmi Geek metapost »

    December 03, 2006

    Comments

    magy_15

    Haven't seen either Don yet (I'll get to it eventually, I'm sure), but based solely on songs found on youtube.....

    New Yeh Mera Dil is better than old. This surprised me. I was expecting the opposite, but Kareena actually did pretty well and Big B was almost expressionless.

    New Khaike pan is better than old. In this case, both actors were adequate. I think the choreography of the new one is more fun.

    Jiska mujhe tha intezaar in the old Don was smokin'! Unlike in Yeh Mera Dil, Big B came alive.

    carla

    Magy, thanks for your comment! These things are very much a matter of opinion. :) I think that the new "Yeh mera dil" and "Khaike paan" range from bad to awful, as I mentioned in the review of the new film.

    On the original "Yeh mera dil," Amitabh was was bored and trying to leave; in contrast to Shah Rukh, who was receptive to Kareena's advance and not in a hurry to get anywhere. So seeing the clip in context might change your perspective a bit.

    As I said in my review, I'd take Amitabh over Shah Rukh any day, so the new songs are already starting with a handicap. Add to that the damage that SEL did to two of the best classic songs there are, and, well, that's my opinion.

    Daddy's Girl

    It really is a matter of personal taste, I agree with you on that. Like you, I absolutely love the oldies - I even have an entire blog dedicated to all things Dharmendra-related (although it's actually more like all things Bollywood-related). I love the magic, the music, just the entire feel of the oldies, but I must admit that I did like the new 'Don' very much, just as much as the old one... and (shhh..) maybe even more. I like SRK just as much as I like Amit-Ji as well... and I love Amitabh Bachchan A LOT, so that's saying something. And although I didn't like Kareena in 'Yeh Mera Dil' (very dodgy dancing), I loved SRK in 'Main Hoon Don'. I just thought the film was super-cool. But I digress. I actually came on to tell you how much I love your blog and that I'll be a regular visitor - I love the way your love for film shines through.

    carla

    Thanks for the kind comments Daddy's Girl - I left a couple on your site as well and have added you to my list of links over on the right.

    New Don v. Old Don - this is one of those debates, I think, that will rage until the end of time. I give New Don credit because I liked it *much* more than I expected to. But given my innate preference for the classics, it won't ever take the top spot for me.

    Amit

    Oh, me thinks it's difficult to top Helen in "Yeh Mera Dil". Kareena Kapoor doesn't even come close to matching her sexiness in that song. Big B looked bored because he'd already had his fun with Helen and wanted to get going.

    And, only in a Bollywood movie can an actor with a limp walk a tight-rope wearing shoes and carrying his kids in each arm!! Such fun.

    ~Amit

    Meera

    Nothing will match the original Don! It was a very entertaining movie. Amitabh at his best especially in the scene where he tells helen after the song Yeh mera dil, "Bahar tumahare saarey Aunty khadey hein" meaning the cops. What a cool scene!

    Also the scenes where zeenat aman is trying to get her revenge on the other amitabh who is pretending to be the don and the song "jiska mujhey tha intezaar". Kishore kumar's songs were really good in the movie.

    I am not even tempted to watch a single scene from the new Don although I own the DVD!

    ayush

    Dear Webmaster,

    Greetings,
    We are handling online marketing for our clients; In the process of Link building we need Bollywood related websites. We would like to request you to place my link at your site at PR o + pages and in return same we will give you PR + in return.

    After verify our links in your website link will be added within 24 hours of back links.
    Our Linking information:

    Url : http://www.bollywood-stars.net
    Title : Bollywood news
    Desc. : Latest Bollywood News, wallpapers, bollywood Rumors, bollywood gossips, television news, music and movie reviews.

    Your link will be added here:

    http://www.amrutapatki.org/fan-sites.html

    We are hoping an early and positive response from your side. Kindly also drop me a line
    regarding title/description to be used while placing your links.
    Contact me as soon as possible to do mass linking with our network websites. Chat

    singh.ayush285@gmail.com

    I am waiting your reply
    Thanks
    Ayush Singh

    hilly hill

    original don ,it's foolish to compare with sarukh khan's don..................

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Working...
    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    Working...

    Post a comment