My Photo

Filmi Geek's blogs

Become a Fan

Filmi Geek on Twitter

    follow me on Twitter

    « Chameli (2003) | Main | Morning Raga (2004) »

    October 09, 2006

    Comments

    Roberta Fosterd

    Looks great! I found lots of intresting things here. Many thanks.

    maxqnz

    I can't believe I haven't commented on this excellent film. I adore the music, and I loved your comment:

    "In the first expression of the film's delightfully unsubtle theme of Indian syncretism and unity, the last time the boys are together they are sitting at the feet of a statue of Gandhi on August 15 - Indian Independence Day."

    I think this is the problem I have with Gowariker's earnestness, à la Swades and apparently, Jodhaa Akbar. He does the "message" bits with the same crude unsubtlety of the example you cite from AAA, but there is aboslutely NO WAY I could see him unbending and sticking SRK or Hrithik in a giant Easter egg. From Shree 420 to AAA, the message movies of old seemed to grok the point that you could put down the sermon cudgel from time to time and just have fun, whereas Gowariker appears to view the idea of fun with the sort of disdain the Puritans had for the concept.

    carla

    max, interesting comparison between AAA and Gowarikar. Although I think there was a lot that was fun about *Lagaan* it's not the romping kind of you're talking about; and I am also starting to think that *Lagaan* may be the exception rather than the rule of Gowarikar films.

    Folks - just a quick comment to everyone - I have slowed the blogging down to a trickle for the last month because of a non-blog project I got involved in that has sucked up altogether too much of my time. I finally put up a new review today and have a few more in the pipeline. I miss watching Hindi films and writing reviews for FG so I hope to be back to it at a reasonable clip soon.

    maxqnz

    "I think there was a lot that was fun about *Lagaan* it's not the romping kind of you're talking about; and I am also starting to think that *Lagaan* may be the exception rather than the rule of Gowarikar films."

    Yes, I agree that there was a lot of fun in Lagaan, and that Lagaan maybe an exception to his norm. Much of the fun came from the relationship between Bhuvan and GAuri, and was expressed in the songs, especially Radha kaise na jale. The successful integration of a decent love story also marks Lagaan apart from Swades, it seems to me.

    the ppcc representative

    Just took the plunge and bought this today. Have watched the first half. Am in love. God promise, am in love!

    Vox_populi

    Did anyone else notice the plot similarities between Amar, Akbar, Anthony and Chalti Ka Naam Gaadi? Especially the end where the heroine is forced to marry the villain's son in a similar type of house. Also the imagery of the three brothers driving the same car with their wives.

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Working...
    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    Working...

    Post a comment

    Blog powered by TypePad

    Blogosphere